Iris may be no Siri, but that's not saying much

-
Iris was a response to Siri, created during an eight hour "hackathon" at Dexetra, the creators of Iris. It's available on the Android Marketplace.

I installed Iris and decided to have a little fun with it. And in return I guess Iris decided to have a little fun with me.

I tried to ask it two questions:
  1. Who is Matthew Robertson
  2. Who is Kirk Tuck
It missed both. I can see how it missed identifying Matthew with such an unbounded question, but it missed identifying Kirk by a country mile. Apparentely I have an accent (must be my Scottish ancestry). Iris kept confusing 'Tuck' with 'Talk', with the amusing results you see.

While Siri is still in beta, Iris is definitely in alpha. While I've only shown a few questions, Iris, when you're careful what you ask, is surprisingly good at finding answers (which, come to think if it, is the way most flesh-and-blood people are as well).

I wonder if Iris is capable of passing the Turing test in its current state. The answer is probably no, but then I know a lot of flesh-and-blood people who couldn't pass it either.

The foundation for building verbal assistants such as Iris already exists on Android. It's just a matter of mashing up the various bits to create something useful. This is one reason why I like Android. It's the 21st century digital equivalent of those old electronic learning labs I had when I was a kid. The Android platform contains a rich environment of services and functionality for writing just about anything.

Comments

  1. Matthew RobertsonNovember 06, 2011

    So of course I had to try this.

    Asking Siri about my own name was too easy, it just pulled up my own information from my contacts. I then told it to search for Matthew Robertson on the web, which brought me straight to the search results page in Google. No surprises there.

    Asking "Who is Bill Beebe" stressed it a little more, because that's not an exact match to the information that I have in my Contacts. So instead it returned three partial matches, and then asked me which one was correct. Not bad.

    But there was nothing, absolutely nothing, that I could do to make Siri hear "Tuck" instead of "Talk". I care-ful-ly anun-ci-ated, changed emphasis and speeds, tried different context: I just got back "I don't understand 'Talk in the sheets'." All I could do was spell out TUCK, which was no problem, and search Google that way.

    Using Siri still feels a bit like the talking dog: I'm amazed that it can do anything, even when it gets a lot of it wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  2. BillNovember 06, 2011

    And so I went back and asked "Who is Bill Beebe" and it went looking for "Who is Bill Baby". I tried three times and it only got it right once.

    Then I asked Iris to call my wife. After four attempts I just gave up after it came back and said repeatedly "Call who?"

    Yes, Iris is alpha-level software and definitely needs more work.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

All comments are checked. Comment SPAM will be blocked and deleted.

Popular posts from this blog

A Decade Long Religious Con Job

-
Image
I rarely write inflammatory (what some might call trolling) titles to a post, but this building you see before you deserves it. I've been seeing this building next to I-4 just east of Altamonte/436 and Crane's Roost for nearly 12 years, and never knew who owned it. Today on a trip up to Lake Mary with my wife I saw it yet again. That's when I told her I wanted to stop by on the way back and poke around the property, and photograph any parts of it if I could. What I discovered was this still unfinished eighteen story (I counted) white elephant, overgrown with weeds and yet still under slow-motion construction. It looks impressive with its exterior glass curtain walls, but that impression is quickly lost when you see the unfinished lower stories and look inside to the unfinished interior spaces. A quick check via Google leads to an article written in 2010 by the Orlando Sentinel about the Majesty Tower. Based on what I read in the article it's owned by SuperChannel
Read more

Ten Reasons to Ignore Ten Reasons to Dump Windows and Use Linux

-
There is a tradition amongst the hard-core Linux aficionados to extol Linux's various virtues as a list of 10 or more reasons to substitute (as in "dump") an existing Windows installation with Linux. There's no reason to point them all out; a simple Google search (" 10 reasons to use Linux ") will provide you with such lists stretching back through the years, as well as hours of entertainment. One very recent list caught my eye over the weekend, published by PCWorld. Their article, " Ten Reasons to Dump Windows and Use Linux ", seems to have hit a nerve with me. Normally I just ignore such journalistic pap, since the majority of it comes courtesy of one ill-informed blog or another (such as this one). But in this instance a "real" publication put some time and journalistic "credibility" into this list, which places it in front of a wider audience than the typical blog poist (again, such as this one). So let's consider al
Read more

Former Eclipse user re-evaluates Eclipse 3.3M5

-
Image
I've been using NetBeans for a while now, starting with version 4.2 in beta. One of NetBeans' key selling points (in my not-so-humble-opinion) is Java GUI building with Matisse . That feature continues to be quite powerful and unrivaled, especially for a free-as-in-beer IDE. I even wrote a lovely paean to the wonders of NetBeans and why I moved away away from Eclipse to NetBeans . Now, it looks like I may have to eat some of those tastefully written words. What you're looking at above is a complete Ruby on Rails project hosted and running within Eclipse 3.3 Milestone 5 on Windows XP. Milestone 5 was released this past Friday, February 9th. I installed it Saturday, and then went on a plugin hunt to fill out additional features and capabilities. Why did I decide to re-install Eclipse, especially a milestone? So that I could get a complete integrated development and test capability in one convenient package for Ruby on Rails. Like a lot of other folks I've been playing
Read more