Skip to main content

An Update to "I Am Not A Lawyer"

I wrote an opinion piece in which I flamed Thomas R. Nicely's assertion that Microsoft, through nefarious means, was forcing everyone to use nothing but Microsoft development tools under Vista. Nicely was using an obsolete version of gcc and djgpp to build applications, and Nicely had found a bug in that combination that kept him from allocating more than 32MiB under Vista. His sample code did indeed fail under Vista (and Windows Server 2003 as I discovered) when built with his tool chain. Lewis Metler (lamlaw) picked it up and used it to bolster his case against Microsoft, wondering if this was yet another attempt by Microsoft to further their monopolistic lock. Metler's done a lot of good writing about Microsoft's abuses and showcasing excellent examples, but Nicely's page is not one of them.

At the time of my original post I stated that Nicely's problems were operator error and feet dragging on his part. In his original post, Nicely stated he was using gcc 3.0.2 and djgpp 2.03. I pointed out that either of those tools (if not both) were long in the tooth and contributed to his problems.

And so it stayed until I got a comment on the entry a few days ago, where the commenter noted that Nicely stated he was using gcc 4.12 (instead of 4.1.2; call me anal, but version numbers should be properly stated). I went back, and sure enough, his original page had been updated and more information added. He also added points to the end of his page lamenting how people felt he was at fault. It was at this point I decided to get to the bottom of his problem, at least to my satisfaction. And so I grabbed and installed Trolltech's Qt Windows Open Source 4.2.3 on Windows Server 2003 and Vista Home Premium.

Windows Server was installed by me on an Athlon 64-based Boxx at work. I installed the 32-bit version. Vista Home Premium came installed on my daughter's new Toshiba notebook, a Satellite A135. I installed Qt 4.2.3 on both, and in the process, installed MinGW. MinGW comes with gcc 3.4.2 and a minimal set of tools and libraries to build C and C++ applications on Windows. I use it in conjunction with Qt to build portable open GUI applications between Linux and Windows. I also used it to successfully build Nicely's sample C code. The results of the compile and run follow.

I ran the test first on Windows Server 2003. I unzipped the sources from Nicely's website and ran his pre-compiled binary. Sure enough, it failed as he indicated. I then recompiled his example code and re-ran the test again with my binary (vista2.exe). It succeeded, as you will note below.


I then borrowed my daughter's notebook long enough to install the same set of tools and run the same tests again. As before, Nicely's binary failed, and my built binary ran successfully.


I should note that even though I did not execute a directory listing, the size of the binary built was the same on both Windows Server 2003 and Vista (as it should be).

This just goes to reinforce my opinion that (1) Nicely is wrong in his assumption and that (2) he needs to use a better set of tools that what he has. I have used both Cygwin and MinGW on Windows, and for the cross-compilation and utility writing I perform, they've never given me trouble. I consider Nicely's problem solved (to my satisfaction). I think Nicely needs to upgrade his open source development environment and go find something else to complain about.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A Decade Long Religious Con Job

I rarely write inflammatory (what some might call trolling) titles to a post, but this building you see before you deserves it. I've been seeing this building next to I-4 just east of Altamonte/436 and Crane's Roost for nearly 12 years, and never knew who owned it. Today on a trip up to Lake Mary with my wife I saw it yet again. That's when I told her I wanted to stop by on the way back and poke around the property, and photograph any parts of it if I could.

What I discovered was this still unfinished eighteen story (I counted) white elephant, overgrown with weeds and yet still under slow-motion construction. It looks impressive with its exterior glass curtain walls, but that impression is quickly lost when you see the unfinished lower stories and look inside to the unfinished interior spaces.

A quick check via Google leads to an article written in 2010 by the Orlando Sentinel about the Majesty Tower. Based on what I read in the article it's owned by SuperChannel 55 WA…

first night for the gingersnaps

The first night has passed and the two have managed to survive, in spite of what their tiny hearts might have thought when first arriving. Greebo, the larger of the two, has been in hiding the entire time so far. Ponder has spent the time zipping in and out of hiding spots, checking things out, and learning just how comfortable pillows are for resting your head.

During the night I felt the tiny body of Ponder hitting the bed as he leaped up on the side, and then climbed to the top to run around on top of me. At least once he play-attacked my fingers. He might be small but his claws are still quite sharp.

When I got up in the morning the bowl of cat kitten food was fairly well depleted. It's been refilled and fresh water put in the big dish on the floor. I'm assuming that both Greebo and Ponder are feeding and drinking. I have seen Greebo under the furniture peeking out at me when I went looking for him. I'm leaving him alone while he continues to adjust.

So far the guys h…

cat-in-a-box channels greta garbo

So I'm sitting at my computer, when I start to notice a racket in back. I ignore it for a while until I hear a load "thump!", as if something had been dropped on the floor, followed by a lot of loud rattling. I turn around and see Lucy in the box just having a grand old time, rolling around and rattling that box a good one. I grab the GX1 and snap a few shots before she notices me and the camera, then leaps out and back into her chair (which used to be my chair before she decided it was her chair).

Just like caring for Katie my black Lab taught me about dogs, caring for Lucy is teaching me about cats. She finds me fascinating, as I do her. And she expresses great affection and love toward me without coaxing. I try to return the affection and love, but she is a cat, and she takes a bat at me on occasion, although I think that's just her being playful. She always has her claws in when she does that.

She sits next to me during the evening in her chair while I sit in mi…